What is a systematic review?
A systematic review aims to identify all previous research on a particular topic, according to set criteria. The pre-specified criteria determine what will be included or excluded. For example, some reviews only focus on all RCTs published on a topic, whereas other reviews will include a wider range of study types and literature, including grey literature. Existing evidence is found through a rigorous, comprehensive search across various databases. Once the evidence has been identified, it is critically appraised and synthesised to produce an overall picture of the landscape of research available on a topic, including strengths and weakness of the literature.
Are you planning a systematic review or other type of review?
A systematic review is just one type of literature review. The term ‘literature review’ is an overarching name for any paper that incorporates findings of previous studies to present an overview of a topic. Some literature reviews take a more systematic and strictly-defined approach than other reviews which may be quicker to produce.
Other types of literature reviews include:
- Scoping review: a broad exploration of the extent of literature available on a topic, often without formal appraisal of quality.
- Narrative review: a review where the literature is explored thematically or chronologically, with some evaluation but not full critical appraisal, and without the same rigorous methods as a systematic review.
- Rapid review: a scaled-back form of systematic review adapted to time constraints, usually covers a policy or practice issue, summarised to provide quick information for decision-making.
- Systematised review: incorporates some elements of a systematic review, often undertaken by a single individual, so limited time and resources prevent it from being a full systematic review.
- Umbrella review: a review of existing systematic reviews on a topic.
Systematic reviews usually involve multiple reviewers working over an extended period of time. They take a considerable amount of time and resources, but are considered as one of the highest levels of the evidence pyramid. However, other types of literature reviews may be more suitable in certain scenarios. To find out which review type might be most appropriate for your project, have a look at the Right Review Tool.
What support does the library service offer?
We can provide advice across many stages of the systematic review
process, but the key support we offer is running literature searches on your
behalf. We can run initial searches to help you scope out the topic, so that
you can decide on the parameters of your research question. This will also
inform your inclusion and exclusion criteria.
When it comes to your full systematic search, on which your
screening will be based, we can work with you to develop a comprehensive and
rigorous search strategy. Once the strategy is agreed, we can then adapt and
run the strategy across different bibliographic databases and export the
results. We can de-duplicate the results in our reference management software
before sending you the RIS file of results for screening.
To a lesser extent, we can provide support in other stages
of the process, for example, with guidance related to: registering your
protocol at the start, critical appraisal checklists, referencing and
identifying journals for publication.
If you would
like to request support from our knowledge and evidence specialists, please find
more information via our website: https://www.mtw.nhs.uk/knowledge-and-evidence-specialist-services.
